Consumer psychology
Why people value something more once they own it, and what that means for returns
The endowment effect says owning a thing raises its value to the owner.
Manish Kumar Singh4 min read
Standard economic theory says an object is worth the same to a person whether they hold it or not. The price they would pay to get it should roughly equal the price they would demand to give it up.
Experiments from 1990 found otherwise. People who had been handed an ordinary object demanded much more to part with it than others were willing to pay for the same thing. The pattern, called the endowment effect, is also contested.
What the 1990 mug experiments tested
Daniel Kahneman, Jack Knetsch and Richard Thaler published "Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem" in the Journal of Political Economy in 1990 (volume 98, issue 6, pages 1325–1348). The design was simple. Consumption goods, such as coffee mugs, were randomly given to half the participants. A market for the goods was then run.
The Coase theorem supplies the prediction. If ownership is assigned at random, some mugs land with people who value them little and some people without mugs value them highly. Trading should move mugs toward the people who want them most, and about half the mugs should change hands.
A hypothetical makes the arithmetic plain. In a room of 100 people with 50 mugs handed out at random, theory expects roughly 25 trades. If sellers' minimum prices sit well above buyers' maximum prices, far fewer deals clear.
What the experiments found
The authors report that willingness to accept greatly exceeded willingness to pay. Owners asked for much more than non-owners would offer. Observed trading volume was always significantly less than the theory predicts.
The authors also checked whether the cost of transacting could explain the shortfall. They ran markets for induced-value tokens, which are worth something only because they can be redeemed for cash. Those markets produced the predicted volume. That result points away from transaction costs as the cause of the low trading in mugs.
They also report that the gap persisted in market settings that gave participants chances to learn.
What it implies for returns and guarantees
Stacy L. Wood applied the idea to remote purchases in a 2001 Journal of Marketing Research article. Buying by catalog or online involves two decisions. The first is whether to order. The second is whether to keep the item once it arrives. Before delivery, buyers lack key experiential information, so the first decision carries risk.
Lenient return policies reduce that risk, but retailers may avoid them because they expect more returns. Wood argues that the endowment effect suggests some surprising benefits of leniency to the retailer. Her three experiments support the idea that product ownership depends more on perception than possession.
The research Wood reports concerns return policies.
Leniency has a cost. A review of 22 academic papers, led by Narayanan Janakiraman of the University of Texas at Arlington, found that lenient monetary policies such as a 100% money-back guarantee can increase purchases. They can also increase returns. Leniency in time or effort was likely to produce fewer returns, according to Janakiraman.
J. Andrew Petersen of Pennsylvania State University studied returns in the Journal of Marketing Research in 2015. He found that a satisfactory return experience lowers the perceived risk for customers unsure a product is right for them. He gives an example in which a shopper might pay $25 for a shirt at one store but $30 at a store with easier returns. Janakiraman also cautions that a lifetime return policy can result in people taking advantage, and says the best policy depends on the type of product and consumer.
Wood's three experiments support the idea that product ownership depends more on perception than possession.
Where the effect is weaker or disputed
The first limit comes from the 1990 paper itself. For tokens valued only for redemption, no endowment effect would be expected, and the markets traded at the predicted volume. The paper expects no endowment effect for goods bought for resale rather than for use.
The second limit is a direct challenge to the measurement. Charles Plott of Caltech and Kathryn Zeiler of Georgetown published their study in the American Economic Review in June 2005 (volume 95, issue 3, pages 530–545). They tested whether subject misconceptions about the elicitation procedure, rather than preferences, explain the reported gaps between willingness to pay and willingness to accept.
They modified the Becker-DeGroot-Marschak mechanism and gave participants extensive training before collecting valuations. They tested both lotteries and mugs. Under those procedures they report that they "observe no gap" between the two measures.
The authors say this casts doubt on reading such gaps as evidence of loss aversion or prospect theory. They also say more evidence is needed before firm conclusions can be drawn. The dispute is therefore about how much of the gap reflects real preferences and how much reflects how valuations are collected.
For a business, the practical reading is cautious. The 1990 results and the return-policy experiments support the idea that possession changes how people value things. The 2005 study reports that the gap disappeared under its modified procedures.
What it changes about a decision
A generous refund can lift purchases and lift willingness to pay by lowering perceived risk. It can also lift returns, particularly when the leniency is monetary.
Time and effort leniency behave differently, according to Janakiraman. A longer window can reduce pressure to decide, though Janakiraman notes that people may postpone the decision.
Petersen says companies that do not factor in how much returns affect the bottom line, and how a return affects later behavior, aren't as good at predicting whom to market to. The sources describe general patterns. They do not say what it will do for a particular product. Janakiraman says the best policy depends on the type of product and consumer.
Goods bought for resale are a different case. The 1990 paper expects no endowment effect for them, and its token markets, which are valued only because they can be redeemed for cash, traded at the predicted volume.
A weekly letter on how people think, buy and work
One idea every Tuesday on psychology, marketing, sales, productivity and technology, with one thing to try that week.
Sources
- Experimental Tests of the Endowment Effect and the Coase Theorem — Journal of Political Economy (Kahneman, Knetsch and Thaler, 1990)
- The willingness to pay-willingness to accept gap, the "endowment effect," subject misconceptions, and experimental procedures for eliciting valuations — Caltech Library / American Economic Review
- Remote purchase environments: The influence of return policy leniency on two-stage decision processes — Duke Scholars / Journal of Marketing Research
- Lenient return policies can increase sales — American Marketing Association